If you’re new to sewing, you might be wondering whether it’s worth it to invest in an expensive, premium sewing machine or if you should stick to an inexpensive machine. And if you’ve been sewing for quite a while and are still using a budget machine (like me!), you might have the same question. Last month I got the chance to try out the Janome Skyline S5, a truly premium sewing machine, for a few weeks, and I think I’ve figured out the answer to that question. I’ll tell you a little bit about this machine and compare it to the budget machine I currently sew on to help you decide if it’s worth it to invest in an expensive sewing machine.
Note: there are some affiliate links in this post.
I do most of my sewing on a super inexpensive Brother sewing machine (you can get an updated version on Amazon
Wrong. As I spent a few weeks sewing with the Skyline, I realized that 90% of my sewing frustration comes from using a budget machine, and that if I ever had the chance to sew on the Skyline full time, I’d likely be sewing all. the. time. (The other 10% of my sewing frustration comes from my own stupidity, in case you were wondering.)
The difference between a budget sewing machine and a premium machine comes down to 2 things in my opinion: 1) premium machines are much more automatic, and 2) premium machines are much more customizable.
Sewing is quite repetitive and extremely detail oriented, so anything that can be automated by a machine is not only handy, it also contributes to a better looking final product. For example, I hate making buttonholes on my machine. I have to do everything manually, and it’s hard to get things to line up right and look good. The Janome has a completely automatic buttonhole plate that makes buttonholes a breeze (you don’t even have the measure anything – you just place the button you’ll be using in the plate and it figures everything out for you!). Lots of other things are automated, too, like auto locking stitches at the end of each seam so you don’t have to backstitch, and threads that automatically get pulled to the backside of the fabric and clipped for you. I’m kind of a lazy seamstress, so I loved all the things this machine could do for me. It’s full of features and details that made sewing simpler and more enjoyable.
Sewing is also full of lots of different situations. The same settings and stitches that work great on cotton fabric are terrible for knit fabric, and the same method for hemming a gathered skirt doesn’t work so well for a circle skirt, etc. So the ability to customize how the machine sews is really wonderful, and will eliminate most of the frustration involved in sewing. For example, sewing on knits can be really tough on basic machines because knit fabric often gets stretched out as you sew, making it look terrible, and you can’t use a normal straight stitch or the seams will pop when the garment is worn. The Janome Skyline S5 has all sorts of extra features to make sure this won’t be a problem: you can reduce the pressure on the foot so fabric doesn’t get stretched out; it comes with an even feed foot to make sure the fabric feeds nicely, and it has a super durable stretch stitch that looks like a straight stitch but stretches beautifully (no more popped seams!).
You can change and customize just about every part of the sewing experience with this machine: stitch length, stitch width, pressure, tension, feed dogs up or down, etc. You can even sew using a knee bar instead of a presser foot if you want! And that’s not even mentioning the hundreds of different stitches you can easily choose using the digital controls (including the entire alphabet!). Add in a different foot for every different thing you’d like to do, and this machine really makes sewing easy.
When I realized how much this machine could do I was worried it would take me forever to figure out how to use it, but 10 minutes out of the box I was sewing my kids’ names into scrap fabric. The instruction manual is very easy to follow and I felt familiar with the machine very quickly. Can you tell I love it? I don’t want to send it back! Maybe they just won’t notice if I keep it…
If you quilt, you’ll love this machine. It comes with a quilting guide bar for quilting parallel lines, has automatic stippling and clasp stitches, and has specific settings to make free motion stitching simple. There’s even a few special stitches made to look like hand quilting.
So, back to the original question: is it worth it to buy an expensive sewing machine?
Well, the answer is that it depends. If you’re just starting out and you aren’t sure whether you’ll love sewing, the newer version of the Brother machine I have
But if you’ve been sewing for a while and you have the funds, I’d definitely recommend a premium machine like the Janome Skyline S5. If you sew regularly, you’ll save huge amounts of time and frustration by upgrading to a nicer machine. It’s certainly a splurge, but if you have the option, wouldn’t you like to splurge on something that will make the hobby you already enjoy even more enjoyable? I can only imagine how much more I would have enjoyed sewing when I first started learning if I’d had a machine like this to work with. If you want to learn more about the Janome Skyline 5S, visit the Janome site.
So, are you interested in seeing what I used the Janome Skyline to make? I sewed up this holiday party outfit for my daughter that’s featured in the newest issue of STYLO magazine:
I was a little nervous about hemming that full circle skirt made from slippery material, but it was an absolute breeze with the rolled hem foot on the Janome. The detail on the top of the dress is made from lots of pieces put together, meaning I had some pretty thick sections to go through, but that was no problem either.
The dress is the Scene VI Dress pattern from CaliFaye Collection, sewn up in a polyester shantung from Jo-Ann Fabrics. The sweater is the Heidi&Finn Ballet Sweater, upcycled from a thrifted sweater, with the addition of puffed “princess” sleeves.
To see even more photos of the outfit as well as over two hundred pages of amazing sewn kids’ clothes inspiration, visit STYLO magazine. I’ll be back on Friday with more photos and a tutorial for how to add puffed princess sleeves to any pattern – see you then!
Thanks a lot now you’ve got me drooling over a nice new machine with all the bells and whistles, when I can barely afford the fabric to sew on :-). Luckily I have a large stash of fabric. Looks like I’ll be saving and saving for a new machine to replace my simple Singer. Maybe if I get my treadle machine going I won’t feel so bad.
So sorry! I’m drooling over it too, and now I have to pack it up and send it back 🙁 Time to start saving…
They didn’t let you keep it? That bites!!
I have just found your website and thank you for your very helpful review.
I have been sewing for many years on an inexpensive machine with zig zag and manual button hole. I don’t sew a lot, mostly dolls clothes for my grand daughters using knit fabrics. My machine copes with a basic zig zag but tensions on stretch fabrics can be difficult. It is time to invest in a better machine so would you recommend a serger to use in addition to my machine or replace it completely with a better one in the $400 range. Not unfortunately the one you tested. My current machine can go to my oldest grand daughter to continue the craft thru the generations
Buy a serger for knits. A more expensive sewing machine won’t help you much. You’ll love your serger. I have a $10,000 Bernina 830 Big Mistake. They saw me coming. Berninas are half the machine at 10x the price. I still like my cheap Walmart Singer for some things. I should have bought a commercial multi needle embroindery machine and kept my Singer for regular sewing and I’d have $$ left over. I have a Babylock serger and love it. I use it mostly for seaming.
Thank you a millon times. I have ask that question so many time. I was just about to buy a Bernina for 10,000.00. ( I really can’t afford it). I have a brother machine that sews and embroidery and I loveit! I am so glad You told this. I can’t see the difference. I have a Singer futura Quartet also and it works wonders. I wonder why myself why did I think I needed that expensive machine? Thank you again for your Honesty!
I have one of the better brother machines. When I went from sewing on a very old bernina to this new brother embroidery/sewing machine I thought I’d died and gone to sewing heaven! I can totally relate. You should try out the newer nicer Brother machines. Trust me. They are amazing!!
Sewing heaven sounds pretty good. You probably never sew your sleeves on inside out there, do you? 🙂 Or maybe I’m the only one that still does that…
I never sew sleeves inside out that my s why the seam ripper is my best friend. But all joking aside i have a janome 6600 and I really like it I think everyone is different so I would go cheap at first and then decide how I work and what I sew and choose a machine that works like I think.
I have been sewing for over sixty years and have several machines. One of them is my mother’s 1940’s era White Rotary 77 (black crinkle cast iron) which she used when teaching me to sew. It’s only straight stitch with reverse but I made tons of doll clothes and many an outfit for myself with it. In the late 60’s, Mom bought me a new Kenmore “green machine” model 158-14001 which had – Wow – zig zag and stretch stitches! That was pretty high-tech back then. I used that machine well into my forties and even made 2 wedding dresses with it. I sold it in the ’90’s (which I later regretted) and bought an early electronic Baby Lock that I still have and still runs beautifully. I thought it was expensive back then-$700. Two years ago, I was introduced to quilting and I fell in love with the process. My Baby Lock doesn’t have a needle-down feature which I wanted very badly so I went looking and found a lovely semi-electronic Brother SC3000 machine which does. It’s a sweet machine and sews nicely but I made a big mistake when selecting it because the “throat” space is so small that I couldn’t even fit a baby quilt through it. Duh-h-h-h! But it’s great for piecing and is lightweight enough to go to my weekly quilting group. So-o-o-o-o-o…I went looking and discovered the Brother VQ series high-end, electronic sewing, embroidery and quilting machines. The throat is 11.5″ wide! When I checked out the price I just about fainted, there was no way; not for approximately $10,000! But I’m a determined old cuss and kept looking all over for a bargain. I found a fully serviced, previous-year model Innovis VQ3000 demo model on sale for less than half price. It was still VERY expensive but my sweet hubby bought it for me and I absolutely LOVE IT. It has all of those fabulous bells & whistles, does everything I need and more, plus the huge harp space is a joy. I sew or quilt almost every day and enjoy every minute. This machine is not for everyone, but it’s great for me and was VERY easy to learn, as I’m comfortable with electronics. Recently however, I was becoming nostalgic for my old Kenmore, it was such a great machine. I opened up ebay and there it was – a fully refurbed model just like my original baby. So I bought it, found an original Kenmore table for it and have it set up next to my Brother Innovis. It runs like brand new and is great for piecing and other jobs if I have a quilt under the needle in the big machine. I love using it – it brings back wonderful memories. The little Brother machine stays in my sewing machine cart ready for Fridays.
So why am I babbling away about this? Number one – I love sewing machines – no good reason, I just do. I have a few other machines that I haven’t mentioned above.
Number two, I agree with you in that the machine you should buy depends on several factors:
Your level of expertise, your budget, what sorts of projects you want to sew, your comfort level with electronic devices and your confidence in your own abilities. Once you have defined these parameters, you’ll have a much better idea of what type of machine you should buy.
I am NOT an expert in anything but I have many years of sewing experience and have used lots of different machines. I would start by first identifying the features you need (auto-threading, needle down, double-needle compatibility, auto presser foot lift, decorative stitches, etc.) not the brand. Why? Because I’ve done some research – something you should do as well – and learned a lot. Please bear in mind, my timelines for the following information may be a little off but they’re close, here goes: In the 1960’s, most of Kenmore’s machines were made in Japan with virtually all metal parts. They were built to last and if properly maintained, they will last for generations. And it wasn’t only Kenmores that were made with precision and quality parts – Brother, Singer, Elna, Riccar, Morse, Domestic and other brands also were made to last. There are many beautiful refurbed machines from the 50’s and 60’s available today and they often have many terrific features, reasonable prices, plus manuals, parts & accessories; all readily available online. People like me buy them for sentimental reasons and/or because we want a very dependable back-up machine. Somewhere around the early 70’s, manufacturers began switching to cheaper manufacturing in Taiwan and quality and dependability declined. Machines were built with lots of plastic and nylon parts. Planned obsolescence came into play. And over time, manufacturers began to build machines for one another. For example, Brother makes some of the Baby Lock branded machines and I think the reverse may be true as well. My VQ3000 is virtually the same machine as the Baby Lock Crescendo, except the Crescendo is pricier. As sewing became less popular in the latter part of the 20th century, some manufacturers consolidated. Sadly today’s Singer is no longer Singer. It’s part of a larger conglomerate called SVP (Singer, Viking, Pfaff, I believe). New Home and Janome are one and the same and if I remember correctly, I believe some Janome machines are made in a Brother manufacturing plant (or is it vice-versa?) Except for the ultra-expensive Berninas and Husquvarnas, you’ll find many are made in China. That’s not necessarily a bad thing – my Brother Innovis machine was made in China but it’s a solid, heavy machine (40+ lbs.) with a minimum of internal plastic – I know – I opened it and looked. But if you buy a $99 machine at Walmart, it’s mostly plastic and if it fails, it’s nothing but a throwaway. So don’t buy it. Go visit several dealer stores, let the sales staff know what your expertise level is, the types of projects you want to sew and the features you need then let them show you machines. DO test machines, but DON’T let a salesperson pressure you into buying something over your budget and expertise level with a “special financing” promotion (otherwise known as DEBT-bad move) Take brochures, take notes, go home and compare. Do your research. Take your time, look for bargains on the internet. Search for a machine that suits your abilities, sewing goals and budget. DON’T buy a sophisticated electronic machine that intimidates you or is “amazing” & “does everything”, DO buy a machine – electronic or mechanical – if it suits your needs, and is affordable as long as it isn’t a low-end “cheapie”. DO make sure you understand the warranty and DO register it with the manufacturer. DO ask the dealer (if you buy from one) if they do servicing as well. If not, ask others who sew where they take their machines for service and repairs, The bottom line: look for a machine that matches your skills, sewing plans and budget, regardless of the brand. Last, and VERY important, LEARN HOW TO CLEAN YOUR MACHINE. Keep it clean and it will perform well for you. Good luck.
Ha! I can top that one, I’ve actually sewn sleeves on the wrong side and didn’t catch it until I was inserting the lining. (I think I was suffering from “my-teenage-daughter-is-driving-me-crazy” disease that day.)
I took the plunge this year and bought a new sewing machine. I went with a Viking and have been a much happy sewer since then..
I’ve sewn for over 40 years and was always frustrated with the beginning stitch, jamming, always having to tie off threads, jamming I know I already said that. My machine has many bells and whistles which I am still learning how to use. It’s cut my sewing time down immensely for repetitive tasks. It was expensive but a good investment for my business. If you are serious about sewing I recommend an upgraded sewing machine.
I know! Jammed thread is SO FRUSTRATING! It makes you want to give up sewing altogether. I’m glad you love your new machine!
Yep I took my very old serger in to be serviced and fixed and the lady showed me the wonderful self threading one and said I could trade in my old one and not pay the $200.00 and apply that to the wonderful $1700.00 new one. I still have my old serger and a lot of envy.
I’ve seen the self threading ones and I am so jealous! I still can’t believe how long it takes to change the threads in my serger. But for being 17 years old it works great – thanks!
Hi Autumn,
I came across your site tonight via Pinterest, as I was inspired by the re-style of the bargain sweat pants into a kangaroo pocket skirt. Love.
On topic…I happened to be in Hancock Fabrics today, and had a short chat with a clerk about a sale they were having on sergers. I currently do not own one, but am always jealous of those people who do not need the “instructions if you do not have a serger” listed on most sewing instructions.
The sales clerk mentioned that she has owned her own serger for over 12 years and has NEVER re-threaded the machine. Years ago, her manager told her this simple tip:
Set the tension to zero. Cut the old thread off near the spool; tie a simple knot with the new thread to the old; pull the knotted threads through; re-set the tension. Easy, and just one of the best sewing hacks I have ever heard! I will remember this for when I do buy the serger of my dreams.
I hope this helps you as well. Feel free to blog about it, if you wish.
Great tip! Thanks!
Lifting the foot does the same thing: untensioning the thread so you can do whatever you need to.
Anyway at the needle eye you need to cut the thread to pass it through. This method is used with the industrial sewing machine.
Personally it believe that this method takes longer than threading the machine in the classic way.
I’ve got to try this been retreading my serger for 25 years it’s kinda a pain but this sounds so easy
H-h-m-m-m-m. I never unthread my serger. I just tie the new threads to the old ones above the machine and gently pull them through. No muss no fuss. Does anybody else out there do this?
Having a more expensive machine can be worth it, however, maybe a distinction should be made in that you should have a higher quality machine over a low quality machine. What I mean to say is that some sewing machines are made with plastic gears inside as opposed to metal. With any sort of heavy use (either material weight or length of time sewing) the machine is not going to fare well. I’m thinking those kid sewing machines that are $50.
The machine doesn’t have to be fancy. My first machine was industrial grade but only $100. I needed it to sew through 11 layers of upholstery grade fabric for historical costuming. It was a great little machine but it really needed to be dropped into a table to secure it as the vibrations would make it travel across the work surface. I ended up giving it to a friend when I got a quieter machine and it still works like it did when I first bought it 20 years ago.
Antique machines that are properly serviced will work wonderfully in this regard. The inside parts are made for long use. The machine won’t break down like newer ones do but they are severely limited in what their stitches can do. I’d recommend getting an older, high quality machine if you are on a budget. When you can afford it, upgrade to something really nice that can do some fancy stitching but also is of high quality.
Look out also for flaws in certain models of sewing machines. I got a really nice $600 non-computer machine but didn’t know about a common problem with the machine, namely that the housing of the bobbin would spin free and I would have to take it to a dealer to have them open the machine up and put it back in the right place. It’s cost me $800 in repairs and has done it again. I can’t stand to spend any more money on it.
Go for quality if you’re going to buy a machine and look up what problems users are having that the machine may have.
Thanks for your comment – lots of good things to remember! And I’m cringing that you had to put so much money into that machine – what a pain!
Excellent
I have several machines but my favorite is an old kenmore I found at good will. It was probably pretty innovated when it came out and it sews smoother than any of my other machines
I was looking for a backup/travel machine and so tested out the Skyline S5. It is 9mm and sewed wonderfully like I have come to expect from Janome (I have the 15000 and had the 7700). It comes with a decent amount of accessories for the price range. I know it sounds crazy but I could not get past the look of the machine (imho not a pretty machine). I would have bought the machine if I could have gotten past the look of it. It is well worth the money.
I understand, Pam! The look of it doesn’t bother me, but if you’re going to spend that much money you want everything perfect. I was surprised, though, at just how many more things it can do than my budget machine. It’s like magic!
I also have the 15000, and I love it. I got a skyline S5 and didn’t particularly care for it. I thought I would go nuts going from one machine to the other. I love Janome machines and didn’t think the S5 was all that user friendly. I upgraded to the skyline S7, which has more of the 15000’s features and is much more user friendly than the S5.
It was so good to read your brief endorsement of the skyline s7. Do you still love it and would you recommend it over a 8900?
I am shopping tomorrow!
Do you still like your S7 after this time because I have one as well but was not sure if I made the right decision. I know I am not in position to purchase Bernina but I still have thought about the decision.
Do you still love your S7? I bought one but am not sure if I made a great choice since there are so many out there for the sewing industry.
Thank you!!!
Your princess sleeve tutorial is the first project I want to try from the Stylo magazine. Love your whole look!
Thanks, Audrey! I was so stressed about the photos for STYLO because everyone’s looks are always amazing. Easy to get intimidated 🙂 So thanks for you kind words!
Darn, I was kind of hoping the answer to this question would be “no.” 🙂 I am currently sewing on the lowest end Brother machine you can get, and it works fine for now. I wish I could drop that much money on a machine! Maybe someday I’ll be able to find a good middle-of-the-road option. I’m excited for the tutorial for the princess sleeves. I bought the Heidi and Finn Urban Kimono and want to try out your technique on those sleeves for my girl!
Elise, as long as you are happy sewing on your Brother you are good. Someday, you may want to upgrade and I know you won’t be disappointed. I would recommend going to a dealer as they will offer quality machines and most offer new machine classes and excellent service. There are lots of great manufacturers to choose from. If you are happy with Brother they have some wonderful higher end machines. For now just enjoy sewing on your machine.
Ha ha! I know, I’m so cheap I don’t know if I’d ever actually spend that much on a new sewing machine – and my super cheap Brother really does ok. You’ll notice I never said you “need” an expensive sewing machine. It would just be pretty darn fun to have if that was an option! A couple people have mentioned that the Janome 3160 is a good middle of the road option, so that might be worth looking into. Thanks for your comment!
I got my old Singer (which, admittedly, has only two bells and one whistle – it will do straight stitches, it zig-zags, and it has a combination of the two for hemming) when I graduated from Jr. High. I’m 60, and getting a bit fuzzy-headed – but you can do the math if you want to!
It needed more than a little TLC. I asked the repairman if I could get as good a machine new, if I spent what it would take to make mine run like new. He emphatically told me NO! My machine was made in Germany, not Japan or Korea, and its hefty weight is due to totally metal construction. There is NO PLASTIC on my Singer, anywhere. He told me that the design was better as well, in that the parts do not wear as much from use. So I entrusted my old friend to him instead of trading it in.
He replaced all the rubber wheels and belts, located a replacement for the missing thread guide post, cleaned and oiled the entire mechanism, adjusted thread tension, calibrated the feed dog – and threw in a set of needles for various fabrics, and a set of metal bobbins – all for under $150. My machine is now set to last at least as long as I can expect to be able to use it!
I have no expectation of doing super-fine sewing, but I did sew a man’s suit – all 6 layers of the jacket, and a fully lined pair of pants – with this machine. And while I doubt I will ever sew 11 layers of upholstery fabric together, I did sew 4 layers of heavy-weight canvas with my Singer when making strap supports for a wall-mounted bookcase and I fully expect the machine to manage multiple layers of old-jean denim for a king-size quilt I have in the works!
I would strongly suggest an older Singer – even if you need it repaired or reconditioned – to anyone who wants a simple workhorse of a sewing machine. For most fabrications, for mending, for the occasional heavy-duty task, it offers a combination of simplicity and sheer strength that many of the newer machines cannot deliver, with a much lower price tag.
Thanks so much for this comment! I have my grandma’s old machine and it’s amazing how well it sews. It’s wonderful to know you don’t have to spend $1500 to get a great machine!
I agree, only problem with these machines is the parts are beginning to become scarce. So purchase with caution. The parts that are still available (new) are getting harder and harder to find and are expensive. Just a foot control alone can be upwards of $50. If your tech tells you parts are readily available they are selling you used parts, no guarantee about the life of used parts.
A few years ago I splurged and got a better machine to replace my old inexpensive one. I was not initially looking to buy a new one, but my old one would not stay in time, and it wasn’t worth it to keep getting it repaired. I purchased a Janome 3160 QDC. Price was around $600. It makes sewing a dream!! My mom just purchased the same machine for herself this summer and can’t believe how wonderful it is compared to her older inexpensive machine. I am partial to the Janome brand, but I guess the point I wanted to make was it is possible to get an excellent new machine with some bells and whistles for even under $1500. I agree with Pam, they could have made this model more attractive. If I was Janome, I’d let you keep this one!!
So true, Terri! You don’t have to go all the way up the ladder to get a machine that’s a great improvement on the budget models. Maybe I’ll have to check out the 3160 if I can’t talk Janome into letting me keep the Skyline (if only!).
I was going to say the same thing about this Janome model. I bought it almost a year ago and I am so very happy with it. It works like a dream – even for sewing purses and you can lift the presser foot for thicker materials. It still has a lock stitch which is wonderful, and the price is more than a lot of amazon.com machines, but not as high as most high end machines. The only thing I kinda miss is it would be nice to have a font or two. But I highly recommend this model of Janome to anyone wanting a good quality machine without going inn the $1,000 range.
When my “middle of the road” Viking went into hospital, I bought the Janome 3160 QDP to get me through several quilts and to use as a traveller when the Viking came back. I love that machine. I have hardly used the Viking since. Last week I used this new Janome at Quilt Market for a full day class. It was a really nice machine to use, but I like the 3160 better. It may not have quite as many stitches, but it has the bells and whistles, and it has been quite a workhorse for me. It is less expensive, and I have recommended it to several people. They tried to tempt me with a great deal on the cost of the Skyline at Market, but I am staying with the 3160.
Thanks, Emily – it’s good to know the 3160 is also a great option!
Some sewing machine dealers who take trade in machines also do repairs on sewing machines. Some dealers repair and sell their trade-in machines. Some of these machines are high quality older machines and can be a great value for someone wanting a great machine, but not needing multiple upscale features. I got a great Bernina serger this way and still use it.
Great tip, Lynn – I never would have thought to check on this!
The switch from budget to expensive for me in addition to and more importantly, was the sturdiness of the machine. It’s heavier and just a much stronger workhorse. Pedal to the medal…literally. I can jam through projects and not feel like my machine is going to vibrate off the table.
That being said, I would recommend to anyone on a budget…even a starter, get an old bernina or other old all metal machine for a couple hundred bucks over a new plastic machine. I scored an old Bernina (for my daughter on an $85 budget machine) from a garage sale (with loads of feet!) for $40. I was originally looking for the 1008 on eBay for $300. I normally use and love my Janome MC6500.
Great post! Thanks.
Great idea on looking for an older machine! Even with a tune-up, getting an old machine is often so much less than these newer models (and the old ones last forever!). They sure weigh a ton, though 🙂
I had an Elna since 1967 and switched to Janome in the late 80’s and have never had another brand. When I retired in 2012 I purchased the Janome Horizon Memory Craft 8200QC and the Janome 1200D Professional overlock machine. Love them both and hope they will last me the rest of my sewing life.
I’ve heard such great things about Janome machines but had never tried one before. They’re wonderful!
Is the work area on the S5 noticeably bigger and better than on the Brother? That’s the machine I have, and I have longed for a bigger workspace, and had the Juki’s on my wishlist…
Hi Gretchen! I’d say the workspace is noticeably bigger. I really want to keep it!
I was really hoping your answer would be No haha. I had a friend recently ask my advice on if you need a fancy machine and I of course said No, my basic brother does wonderfully, fancy machines are overrated….I might have to eat my words after reading your review – this machine sounds amazing – especially the buttonhole function!
ps. surely if you agree to test drive it you should be able to keep it right?!?! 🙂
I own 4 Janome machines. One is an older serger which I LOVE. It works like a breeze and it’s really not that hard to thread when you remember how to do it! haha. I also own a 10001….but I had to send it back to Janome to put an entire shaft inside!! What went wrong you asked? The only downside to this machine was that it did all those fancy stitches PLUS embroidery. I think the combination isn’t good for a “home” type machine. The gears are plastic and more likely to break – once replaced the machine NEVER runs the same because gears don’t match up ever again! But I am able to use the 10001 for the fancy stitches – I just stay away from the embroidery which seemed to be a problem. However, I paid $1800 for the machine on “sale” so it was not the best option. Now I own two more – a BASIC janome that has a few fancy stitches, the buttonhole and a few other things. It’s basic but touchy – I have never been able to sew denim or thick materials. My other Janome is a 900 embroidery machine which I love. However, Janome faded out their free embroidery software that came with the machine. Now you MUST purchase a Embird or another embroidery program to be able to download files and transfer to the machine!
So there are some negatives with Janome and paying a higher price for “technology”. I will always keep a back up metal singer machine so if I cannot afford to get them fixed, I have something to sew on! I know that as time goes on improvements are made and Janome has been one to stay on top of changes…but it’s just really hard to think about paying $2,000 for a sewing machine and then it break when you least expect it or you aren’t able to afford additional accessories!!
I’m glad you like the new one…I will have to try it sometime. I’m considering keeping all my 10001 feet/accessories and moving to a newer model that will hopefully last more than two years! 🙂
Also, google the new BABY LOCK serger – they have one that Nancy Z is endorsing that has 8 or 10 cones of thread!! It would make wonderful serging options. Personally I’m drooling over it!! LOL
Amanda
Babylock makes the finest sergers in the world, and, no matter what you hear, they are the ONLY self threading, auto tension made in the world. Worth every pennie.
Hi Lisa,
What year is the Baby Lock that you have? I have one that is several years old but has never been out of the box! I also have the MC6600P which does embroidery and haven’t used that more than a total of about 8 times since buying it several years ago. I am considering trading in at least the MC6000P for something that doesn’t have all the bells and whistles I don’t need. I was just wondering if you had any thoughts on the the MC6000P either. I am feeling overwhelmed with so many separate pieces on a single machine. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated. Thanks so much, Karon
Absolutely agree I have the Ovation and it is WONDERFUL
I’ve always wondered this too. I have a Kenmore (made by Janome) very cheap and manual, but it will sew anything from terry, knit, fleece and cotton without fail over and over. I have a sewing business and have wondered if it was worth the upgrade to a Bernina and the like. I recently went from a cheaper serger to a babylock and OMG, that was SO WORTH the upgrade! Love me some jetair threading. Thanks for the article.
Such a great article! After 16 years of sewing on my very basic Brother machine, I just splurged and got the Janome Memory Craft 6500. Holy Moly it has blown me away. All the sudden sewing is really fun!
I hope you can get your own fancy sewing machine soon because it will change your sewing forever.
Amen.
I originally learned to sew on an inexpensive Kenmore, which was a compact machine. I realized it being so small I couldn’t do much. I couldn’t get a super expensive machine, so I researched and found something middle grade. I got a Janome Sewist and it has made a world of difference. It does not have a computer, which I like, but is made well and sews wonderful. I make clothes, toys, quilt, etc and There is a huge difference with getting a better, higher quality machine,
My regular machine is a 1955 Elna Supermatic. It is a workhorse, even sews leather. It can also be a pain. I also have a Babylock Evolution, which I won. I love it. it does exactly what it is supposed to. Yesterday I bought a second hand Baby lock Quest at a great price. I have a lot of stress in my life as a caregiver. I don’t need it from a machine.
About 5 or 6 years ago I took the plunge and bought a Janome 1600. I had an older Singer and I was frustrated trying to quilt on it because it did not have a needle down feature which, for me, was really important. I was nervous about spending $1000 on a machine (I watch my pennies pretty closely) but I bought my Janome and I could not be happier. I love that machine. The downside is that it is just a straigt stitch machine. Great for quilting because of the larger harp but still I was missing some other things so I bought a Brother CS6000i on Amazon. I love that little machine! So many different stitch choices, auto button hole maker, needle down, needle threader, feed dogs that drop, etc. I recently had to have my Janome serviced. I took it to the best sewing machine repair folks in our area. The downside of that is that it is a Bernina dealership. As much as I would probably adore a Bernina high end machine, there will never be a time that I would feel comfortable spending $2000 much less $8000 on a sewing machine…unless I won the lottery or found a very wealthy husband!
I purchased a JanomeHorizon12000 about 2 years ago as I do embroidery and love every thing it is capable of doing. yes it was expensive and I traded in a Janome 11000.They are both computerized I have the capability of a 9mm stitch width. I had a Janome 2030 which I took to guild as it only weighs 12 pounds. The big 12000weighs almost 27 pounds. I do not like taking it every where. I was at the dealer store the day the Skyline arrived. I had the opportunity to play I am going to tell you I was extremely impressed!! It also has the 9mm feet and is compatible with my12000 . I do not think it looks bad at all!! I like what it is capable of doing.. This day and age sewing machines are like buying a car.. You pay for the bells and whistles and as far as I am concerned you get what you pay for. I am very much a Janome buyer and would not change. This is my personal feelings and my likes. Thanks.
Thanks for your comments, Donna! I’m still trying to decide whether to spring for the Skyline myself…
Hello Autumn I posted a question a week ago and somehow it displayed as number 3 alongside the November posts. I doubt it you or anyone else saw it. I have been checking for a reply but none showing, so I will post again below. thanks
I have just found your website and thank you for your very helpful review.
I have been sewing for many years on an inexpensive machine with zig zag and manual button hole. I don’t sew a lot, mostly dolls clothes for my grand daughters using knit fabrics. My machine copes with a basic zig zag but tensions on stretch fabrics can be difficult. It is time to invest in a better machine so would you recommend a serger to use in addition to my machine or replace it completely with a better one in the $400 range. Not unfortunately the one you tested. My current machine can go to my oldest grand daughter to continue the craft thru the generations
Hello Autumn I posted a question a week ago and somehow it displayed as number 3 alongside the November posts. I doubt it you or anyone else saw it. I have been checking for a reply but none showing, so I will post again below. thanks
I have just found your website and thank you for your very helpful review.
I have been sewing for many years on an inexpensive machine with zig zag and manual button hole. I don’t sew a lot, mostly dolls clothes for my grand daughters using knit fabrics. My machine copes with a basic zig zag but tensions on stretch fabrics can be difficult. It is time to invest in a better machine so would you recommend a serger to use in addition to my machine or replace it completely with a better one in the $400 range. Not unfortunately the one you tested. My current machine can go to my oldest grand daughter to continue the craft thru the generations
Hi Anne! I have a pretty basic sewing machine as well and I don’t love how it copes with knits. My serger does a MUCH better job, so I use it a ton when I sew with knits. I would love a better sewing machine, but I’m not sure I’d give up my serger to get one, so I guess my recommendation would be to go for the serger now, and then try to upgrade the sewing machine in a few years. (That’s assuming that your machine still does ok for the most part.) I guess another option would be to get a newer budget machine like this one for $150: http://www.amazon.com/Brother-Feature-Rich-Stitches-Auto-Size-Buttonholes/dp/B000JQM1DE/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1423926830&sr=8-1&keywords=brother+sewing+machine AND get a basic serger, like this one for $200: http://www.amazon.com/Brother-1034D-Thread-Threading-Differential/dp/B0000CBK1L/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1423926862&sr=8-1&keywords=serger
good luck with whatever you decide!
Another thing to do, is keep an eye on Craigslist, a couple if years ago I bought a Babylock Eclipse for $500. It was in mint condition. It took me a while to find it, but it was WELL WORTH IT! I just kept checking everyday, I wasn’t in too much ? of a hurry to find a Babylock…just be sure to check it out with a friend (for safety) . The lady who sold me hers, had it all set up with different materials for me to try. She had recently upgraded her Eclipse, unbeknownst to her hubby.. Totally my gain!!!? Good luck!
Hi,
Thanks so much for this review. My 18 year old computerized elna has pretty much had it and I regrettably purchased a heavy duty singer machine for $500 which turned out to be average at best. I really should have saved the money and replaced the elna with another computerized machine. It looks like you have sewn fine slippery fabrics with ease, which is what I need. But I also need to sew heavy upholstery fabrics (I have a cushion fetish). I think if it’s a good machine it is pretty good value as you can pay thousands for sewing machines!
Hi Nicole! How frustrating to spend $500 on a machine you weren’t happy with. I hope you don’t have to wait too many years to try something else!
Singer “ain’t” what she used to be. Steer clear.
Absolutely!!!! You will get what you pay for in a sewing machine every time. If you want precision, buy an old Bernina until you can afford a better one. Insist on a true Bernina if you buy a new one, not a Bernette knockoff. At least a 3 series. If you need bang for the buck, Pfaff is the only way to go. More stitches, a built in walking foot, prices start at about 699. Babylock is the most user friendly sewing machine made, again move at least one step up the ladder, maybe a Rachel. Alot of people, and I mean alot, of people love their Janomes. Once again, move up the line, you will never regret moving up. 0% financing is still available most places, and you will never, ever regret it. Go to a reputable dealer, Ask around, if you feel like you aren’t getting the service you deserve, look around. And NEVER, EVER buy a sewing machine online. Sorry, probably steps on toes, but that is the truth.
I completely agree with you! I had a starter machine when I first got married, and it was great. I used it to make lots of curtains and a few simple garments. As I started getting into more complicated things, I would become increasingly frustrated. I thought it was my inexperience. It had gotten so bad, I had completely stopped sewing. At the advice of some older, wiser family and friends, I decided to invest in a better machine. It was like night and day! The machine I bought is not top of the line, but probably a middle range, and like you, I realized that almost all of my frustrations with sewing were from having a machine that could not handle what I wanted to do. Thanks for sharing your experience, and I hope they let you keep the machine.
Hello !
Thanks for this post, and all the comments. All advices are SOOO welcome when asking this question.
I’ve read carefully all your advices, and I have a question : what if the machine of your dreams is never quoted, rated or so on the web ?
Good or bad sign ? (I’m thinking about the Janome DC7060)
Thank you for your help !
(Sorry for my english, it’s not my mother tongue)
Your daughter’s dress is beautiful. I tried the Janome Horizon and had nothing but trouble – After two years and many bobbin holder purchases, I couldn’t stand it and traded this in for a Juki. What a difference – no more explosions while sewing. The Horizon really sounded like it was exploding every time that the bobbin holder broke (can remember this happening at least five times). Janome refused to do anything. Glad that you had good luck with this machine, but I will never purchase a Janome product again.
I reached your blog from Pinterest.
Firstly I thank you for sharing this review with us, the readers.
I was actually looking for reviews for Elna eXcellence 680, which in fact proved to be exactly the same machine as this one in review: Janome Skyline S5. Now I believe I’ll make this investment in this model. Unfortunately I don’t have Janome shop in my country (Greece), so I must go with the Elna’ s model, which I found it in Romania.
I was between Pfaff Expression 2.0, Husqvarna Viking Opal 670 and Elna 680, but because Elna is newer model, I believe I’ll go with it. Husqvarna has 5 years warranty, but reading a review like yours on another website, I learned a lot about some issues you may encounter. What about the Pfaff, since Singer bought them, their reliability is disappointing.
I had a Bernina Bernette Sublime Chicago 7. Well on sewing the machine went perfect. But I had trouble with the embroidery module, so I sent it back for warranty. Finally the answer was they will make a refund. So I said I’ll buy a dedicated embroidery machine, but next year. This year I must have a little patience and make some economies so that I’ll afford to buy this Elna 680/Janome S5.
Phlom
i test drove this machine, I didnt like the look of it. Very boxy. I test drove the buttonholes it didnt come out nicely. im probably going with Pfaff or Bernina. If your going to buy quality but something that isn’t so plasticy.
One thing I’d recommend if you’re looking to upgrade or buy a nice quality machine, is to look for either end of season sales or consider a used machine. I got a very nice quality Janome about ten years ago on sale for $600, from $1100 full price. It’s an outstanding machine that I sew on almost every day. I don’t know what I’d do with out it. There is a quilt shop near my home that sells used machines sold by wealthy women who get a new machine every couple of years and always buy top of the line- so they are good machines and barely used, really. Maybe there is something like that in your area? I would ask around to your local quilt and fabric shops and see if they can help you.
Absolutely! A high-end machine is a much better bargain! I don’t know anything about Janome machines, so I cannot speak to them, but the question wasn’t really about “Should I buy a Janome high-end machine?” After many years of using a Sears machine that came out just before they started offering a free-arm, I finally purchased a Husqvarna. I love it! In addition to the comments made, what I love are the many different pressure foot devices for different applications and the ability to change the position of the needle right or left to accommodate different seam allowance widths. I would love to be in the position of trying out new machines. What a fun and valuable experience you’ve had!
Probably no one will scroll down this far, but here goes anyway! I like the comment of quality, rather than price, being what we need to look for. Vintage machines are much better quality than a new machine, and usually cheaper. New machines are made to be disposable, not to last, no matter how many bells and whistles they have; whereas most vintage machines will last forever with proper oiling. I have over 40 machines, old and new, and I know what I’m talking about. Great machines to look for: Bernina 930 or 830 or 1008, pre 1960s Singers, and the made in Japan, 158 series, Kenmores. My oldest is from 1909 and still running strong. I have one computerized machine that gives me more problems than the rest put together, and it is a good quality Janome. Trust me, go vintage!
I read the latest comments. You who recommended a vintage or fully mechanical machine, you are so right.
But!…
1. I live in Europe and here in Greece this culture of Quilting/Patchworking it is not so popular, altough they exists some clubs, but far away from my location. For this reason the market is not very rich in sewing machines diversity.
2. I need the decorative stitches for my creations. And a mechanical or semi-mechanical can’t offer more than 30-40 decorative stitches.
Since I wrote the first message I was able to make some economies and my WishList became bigger, because I became interested in Pfaff Expression line machines (3.2/ 3.5 / 4.2) because of the IDT system and many decorative stitches (and 5 years warranty) and of Elna Excellence 760EX. The last one is above my economical power, but… you can never know. I also reviewed the Husqvarna Viking 690Q / 960Q and Brother innov-IS 1300 / 1800Q.
But I think I’ll go with Pfaff Expression 4.2… What do you think?
PS: I ocassionaly review your comments so you can give me a litlle help…
The problem with this is that Janome basically paid you to wax lyrical about their product. How can I possibly trust your opinion?
One main thing about Janome sewing machine is it is fairly priced while other branded sewing machines from top brands such as Brother, Singer can’t be purchased at the same price with the same functionalities.
I JUST PURCHASED THE NEW DREAM MACHINE BY BROTHER THE 8500. LOVE, LOVE, LOVE IT !! THE EMBROIDERY IS AWESOME– I AM LEARNING HOW TO SCAN THEN EMBROIDERY MY OWN DESIGNS.
I THINK BROTHER IS VERY GOOD QUALITY– THIS IS MY 4TH BROTHER MACHINE– MY 1ST WAS A BROTHER NX600– WHICH I STILL HAVE– AND IT RUNS AS GOOD AS THE DAY I BROUGHT IT HOME.
I too have 2, yes two brothers that have seized in the past 2 years. Well I am so happy with my purchase yesterday. While life has gotten in the way of my quilting, I to took it out of the box and in minutes was sewing. Can’t wait to finish what I startedon Sunday when my Brother seized.
do you think your article could fit in a few more affiliate links?
I recently upgraded from my now 30 year old Singer to a brand spanking new Bernina Bernette Chicago 5. I took advantage of their special sale and got it for only $500; that’s half price! There’d be no way I would’ve spent more than $500 on any machine, so I was glad to get such a good one. All the stitches! It’s very much like the Janome you tested. Its definitely worth it to upgrade. I can finally do all those buttonholes I’ve been putting off. 🙂
I bought the Janome Skyline S Five before Christmas on sale, saved $500. The best sewing machine,
I love the convenience of of having all the stitches you can choose & being automatic.
I would highly recommend this machine as I am still a beginner with sewing & quilting.
Mary
Do you still love your Skyline S5. I’ve read that the quilting foot moves during sewing. Have you had this experience?
We’re considering Janome S5 or %7 machines for my wife who is a beginner. No question the S7 is a more feature filled machine and a much nicer display. The accuefeed seem a real nice useful feature but doesn’t come on the S5. What concerns me is all that pre- programming . It seems disproportional to the actual sewing time. In other words setting things up manual seems faster and easier at times. With a thousand features which machine is really more user friendly? That said if you do a lot of repeat work then programming a procedure once makes sense sewing, time then is much easier and faster. Having all these variable options is nice but may add to the work load Granted when the time comes when you need a feature its always nice to have it at your disposal.. The simpler S5 does a lot after all and seems simpler. We are torn .
Thank you for your post, I have been looking for a step up from my Singer and considering a Bernina 7 for almost $3,000. I have hear about the Janome and now will seriously consider one.
I have had an 800.00 Huskvarna. And I have a 6000.00 Embrodiery machine. I bought as 150.00 Brother at Wal Mart to carry in my camper and it is as good as my 800.00 one. The newer cheaper ones are better then the older expensive one if you ask me.
I received that machine for my birthday un july2017. It is the best sewing machine ever. I enjoy making all kind of projets. Yes it is worth it. I used to have a kenmore machine it work well for years. With this one it is just better. Having fun sewing
Am I the only one to state that I abhor the Janome 2014? I’ve parked it in a closet and have gone back to my Vintage metal Viking. Design on the Janome is beyond comprension. Totally cheapens the experience.
Has anyone tried Singer Legacy 340 machine
Hi Autumn,
My tip would be to look for a machine in the price bracket above what you want to spend/can afford. Once you find exactly what you want wait for a sale, that way you get more for your money! I love my Janome, it’s quite a basic model but more than I would have been able to afford full price. Also, I tried the machine I eventually bought out in a shop and then ended up buying it from that same stores website for a lot less than it would have cost in store, worth checking online deals!
Regards,
Barbara Harris
hi Autumn,
for the basic use, the regular sewing machine are great at the price range and to comply with its use. but sometimes the machines are given to some extra more features and only for that the price is too high. i think the expensive machines worth it.
Your daughter outfit is really beautiful. In good hands even not so expensive sewing machine can make great stuff.
What is expensive and what is not depends on each person’s budget. I have sewing machine that costs under 300$ read. It is great if sewing is just your hobby, but if you are up to something bigger you’ll need a more expensive model.
G`day i live in australia and i started out with a husqavarna 2000 about 1975 which was great but i decided to upgrade to a brother 2100 sewing and embroidery machine which i loved but it went to god a few years ago and now i have a brother 1500d i only use it for embroidery it does both.( i used the 2100 for sewing) until it died
so now i want a juki hzl 400/500/600 sewing machine. they look fabulous and they cut the threads WOW!
and a different way of forming the stitch! i don`t recognise some of your models but it is great to upgrade.
i also have an old industrial brother up in the garage for doing the model a ford 1928 and 1934 vintage cars
so i have every thing covered. we all need to have something to bring out our creative talents and to encourage the next generation. my daughter has a 2100 which she has outgrown but wants to keep it for her daughter who is 5 and can use with a little help! the one she wants is a brother in the 5000 range about $5000 dollars (i should be so lucky!)