Today I’m showing you how to make three different Christmas Oreo pops. They’re easy to put together and turn out super cute, plus they’re an absolute HIT with the under-10 crowd, which makes them the perfect treat for a class Christmas party!
Seriously, my 6-year-old daughter can’t contain herself around Oreo pops. She LOVES that she can eat the eyes and the reindeer’s nose and even the star on top of the tree. I think we’ll get some small cello treat bags to wrap some of these pops up in so she can deliver them to her friends before Christmas.
How to make Christmas Oreo Pops
Here’s what you’ll need to make them:
- Double Stuffed Oreos (normal ones won’t work)
- Candy melts in red, white, and green
- sucker sticks
- candy eyes
- Christmas color Sixlets (for the reindeer and Santa)
- mini pretzel twists (for the reindeer)
- sprinkles + star sprinkle (optional) for the trees
This quick video shows how each pop is made, but be sure to read the written instructions below for all the details.
ONE QUICK TIP: I don’t think candy melts ever get quite runny or smooth enough on their own for dipping Oreos, so I add Crisco to the melts to thin them out. I’ve read you can also use coconut oil, but I haven’t tried that yet. Just melt the candy, then stir in a few spoonfuls of crisco until it gets to the consistency you like. I probably add about 1-2 tablespoons per smaller size bag of candy melts.
How to make Santa Christmas Oreo Pops
Dip a double stuffed Oreo into melted white candy melts, dipping it a little more than halfway in. Gently push a sucker stick into the bottom of the Oreo, right in the center of the half that is covered white. Place on wax paper and allow to set. (You can do a bunch and then put them in the freezer to set up quickly).
Then, holding the Oreo by the stick, dip the other half into red candy melts, not quite halfway, and place on wax paper. Use a white Sixlet to make the “poof” at the end of Santa’s hat. Use a little extra melted candy to “glue” on candy eyes and allow to set.
(I like to put some melted candy in a ziplock bag and snip a tiny hole at the corner, then “pipe” melted candy on the back of each eye.)
How to make Reindeer Christmas Oreo Pops
Separate a double stuffed Oreo. Dip a sucker stick in melted candy and push it into the cream side of the Oreo, then replace the other cookie and press gently to sandwich the stick inside the Oreo. Allow to set (can be placed in freezer).
Break mini pretzel twists to get antler shapes as shown. This can be tricky and you will end up with extra pieces that don’t break the right way, but keep at it until you get enough (and snack on the ones that didn’t work!). Dip the end of a pretzel piece in melted candy and stick it into the Oreo. Repeat with the other pretzel. Use more melted candy to “glue” on eyes and a red Sixlet nose.
How to make Christmas Tree Oreo Pops
Dip about one third of a double stuffed Oreo into white candy melts, then gently push a sucker stick into the Oreo in the middle of the white candy. Place on wax paper to set.
Put melted green candy melts into a ziplock bag. Snip a small hole in one corner. “Pipe” green candy in a tree shape on the Oreo. Add sprinkles and a star sprinkle if desired.
Easy + cute!
Looking for more Christmas fun? Visit these posts:
Print + Fold Christmas bookmarks
Cinnamon Christmas Ornaments kids can make
25 adorable Christmas treats to make with your kids
Best experience gift ideas for kids
20 cute + easy neighbor gifts for Christmas
25 handmade gifts people actually want
Not Easy Rudolph’s!……double stuff Oreos are not thick enough for pretzels and many cookies broke trying to gingerly take them apart. Had to add a layer of chocolate between wafers to make frosting thick enough for the stick (Wilton Cookie Sticks) and the antlers. Mega stuff Oreos might work but buy extras! Many pretzels tossed until I was able to get antler shapes. Used Wilton candy decorations for the red nose but they will break your teeth…suggest removing them before giving to your child.
They look cute but that’s all I can say. Lots of waste. Not a good day in the kitchen.
I hope I remember not to try these again!