In today’s post: Love the soft brown bread at The Outback Steakhouse? Now you can make it at home with my Outback bread recipe.
My very favorite part of eating out at the Outback Steakhouse is the sweet dark brown bread they bring out before the meal. It’s soft and delicious, with hints of molasses and honey. A few years ago I tinkered with my best dinner rolls recipe to see if I could modify it to resemble the sweet molasses bread from the Outback. I got pretty close, but a few readers let me know their bread didn’t rise very well, so I’ve had another go it. This time it’s just about perfect (IMO): soft, tender, with hints of honey and molasses and a gorgeous brown color. I’m pretty sure you’re going to love my Outback bread recipe!
There’s just not much I love more than soft bread. I usually prefer white bread to wheat, but this brown bread recipe uses half whole wheat flour and it’s amazing! It’s mildly sweet with a lot of flavor from the honey and molasses in it. I could honestly skip the meal and just eat this bread.
This bread gets some color from the molasses and baking cocoa that are in it (don’t worry, it doesn’t taste like chocolate!) but if you want a nice deep brown you’ll want to add some coloring. Most commercial dark brown breads are made with caramel coloring, which is hard to find in your local grocery store. You can mix red/yellow/blue from your standard food colors to get a brown, or pick up some brown paste food coloring from the cake decorating section. You’ll need quite a lot of coloring to get the very dark brown color you see at the restaurant. I used just a bit of brown gel coloring.
Make sure you whip up some butter to serve with!
So before we get to the recipe, let me tell you a little secret: I like this bread even better made as rolls. Actually, I like just about ANY bread recipe better made as rolls. Why? Because they don’t have crust! Rolls don’t take as long to bake and so they stay soft and tender the whole way through. So I’ll show you how to make this bread in small loaves just like you get at The Outback, but then I’ll also show you how to make it as rolls, which is what I do almost exclusively.
Outback Bread Recipe
Download the printable recipe card by clicking here.
And here’s some extra explanation and photos to help you make gorgeous Outback brown bread:
You’ll start by placing the warm water, yeast, and sugar in the bowl of your mixer. The water should feel warm to the touch, but not hot. Give it about 10 minutes to let the yeast proof – it will get nice and puffy looking, like this:
Then you can start adding the other ingredients. First add the whole wheat flour, the butter, the egg, the molasses, and the honey. If you want to add food coloring, do so now. Using a dough hook, turn the mixer on to low and start letting everything combine.
Once that’s going add one and a half cups of bread flour, the baking cocoa, and the salt. Keep mixing until everything is incorporated.
At this point you may need to add 1/4 to 1/2 cup more bread flour. You want the dough to pull away from the sides of the mixer bowl, so add more flour as needed. If the dough is already pulling away from the mixer, you don’t need to add more. It should look like this:
You’re going to let the dough knead for about 10 minutes total to really build up a lot of gluten, which will help give it a nice rise. If it starts sticking to the bowl too much, you can add some more flour to keep it looking like it does in the photo above. After about ten minutes you should have a nice dough that’s smooth and very elastic. You can pinch off a piece and do the “window pane test” – if it’s ready you’ll be able to stretch the dough thin enough that you can see light through it without the dough tearing.
After kneading, turn the dough out and form it into a tight ball. I spray the inside of my mixer bowl and place my dough back inside it to rise. When I’m making this dough in the winter months I like to turn on my oven for a few minutes to warm it up and then turn it off and place the dough inside it to rise. If you do this, be sure you put it in a bowl with high sides and cover it with a damp towel to keep it from drying out.
Rise time will be 60-90 minutes depending on how warm it is. You want the dough to double in size.
Shaping + baking the Outback molasses bread recipe
Once the dough has risen, decide whether you’d like to make your Outback bread into small loaves or rolls. For small loaves, divide the dough into 6 equal sections. Gently press each section into a 6×6 inch square. Roll the square up into a log, pinching the seam at the bottom.
Place each log onto a greased cookie sheet pan. Spray gently with water and sprinkle with cornmeal. Cover with a dry towel and allow to rise until doubled again, about 50-60 minutes. The second rise won’t look as dramatic as the first rise, but you’re still looking for an increase in volume and a nice puffiness:
Bake at 350 degrees for 25-30 minutes until loaf sounds hollow when you tap on the bottom.
How to make Outback bread rolls
Once the dough has doubled in size, separate it into 16 sections and form into balls. Place them in a greased 9×13 pan and let them rise, covered, for another hour until the dough balls have grown in size enough that they touch one another. Bake at 350 for about 20 minutes until cooked through. If you use food coloring, it can be hard to tell when the rolls are done, since they won’t get much browner than they already are. The easiest way to tell if they’re finished is to gently pull one roll away from the one next to it and check to make sure they look baked through. If in doubt, give them another minute or two. Better slightly overdone than doughy inside.
Here’s how I shape rolls. I cut the dough into 16 equal sections, then pick up one section in my right hand. I make a circle with the thumb and forefinger on my left hand, then gently push the dough piece through it, dusting it with flour if needed. Once I’ve pushed the entire piece through, I crimp it together at the bottom. That makes a nice tight ball.
Here’s what the whole process looks like if you’re making rolls:
Outback Bread recipe tips
Ok, I have a couple final tips to make sure your bread turns out amazing:
- Flour: This bread uses two types of flour – whole wheat flour and bread flour. I use white whole wheat flour whenever I’m baking wheat bread. It gives you a bit lighter finished product, but if you only have normal whole wheat flour you’ll be just fine. HOWEVER, you should definitely use bread flour and not all purpose flour. It has a much higher protein content which does a better job building gluten and will make sure you get a good rise on the bread.
- Cocoa: Yes, we use a bit of baking cocoa in the recipe. It adds color and a little depth of flavor, although the bread does not taste like chocolate. DO NOT use dutch process cocoa, as it’s extra acidic and can make it hard for the yeast to rise. Look for natural baking cocoa (like the Hershey’s brand). If you do not want to use cocoa, I’ve had readers recommend substituting instant coffee instead.
- If you need help with bread baking in general, you can click over to my Very best dinner roll recipe. That post includes a step by step video that walks you through the entire process.
Love bread? Give some of these recipes a try:
Easy 4 ingredient artisan bread recipe
The very best dinner rolls recipe
How to make homemade french bread
Better than Olive Garden garlic breadsticks
These look WONDERFUL!!!
I can’t wait to make these! I just have to get molasses. Thanks – very good instructions.
On my way to get molasses and whole wheat flour right now. thnx
again light blue text is very hard for some people to see.
There always has to be one sour apple in the bunch. This is a delicious recipe. Try it it might change your attitude.
When I can’t see a blog’s text very well I highlight it, right click the mouse, select ‘copy’, open a Word Doc , right click again and select ‘paste’. Once it is in the Word Doc I can change the color or font size to be agreeable to my aging eyes. It takes all of 5 seconds. If I don’t want the recipe I delete the document. And I’m grateful the blogger posted it for free when she didn’t have to post it at all.
The recipe looks outstanding. I think I will make it today to go with the pulled pork in the crockpot that’s perfuming the house! Thanks for the labor involved to duplicate the bread!
I am so very sorry for some people ignorance. Don’t pay any attention you can’t buy class. She will eat her words one day and yes the text is hard to read. Have a bless day darling
Agree with Harriet. The world doesnt conform to you! How entitled are you! No one else has a problem here. There are many solutions if you cant see the text well. Also you said “again” if she ignored you the first time take a hint.
WOW! Aren’t you a real sweetheart to someone with a disability! I bet you park in the Handy Capped spots too.
Many people have a problem with low contrast printing. That’s why most (not all) packaging instructions are not black on red. And yes, it does bother others. They just haven’t said it here.
I agree with Richard. Maybe you should have a little less ‘ME’ and a little more ‘WE’.
The point here is that someone took time to perfect and share a recipe that others can choose to enjoy or ignore. It’s rude and thankless to demand she change something just because it’s inconvenient for you. If you do ask, it should at least be respectfully. Whether the poster has time or desire to change is up to them. I think we’re all just tired of snarky people using the comment box.
Are we becoming a culture where we’re not happy unless we’re criticizing or putting someone down. If so, this is not the place to do it.
So very true! Thank you for posting this!
Karen- thank you for posting your comment on some of us who have disabilities.
Autum, love your blog. Looking forward to trying these. Fellow commentors, please be considerate.
Understand how fortunate you are to be able to see and read this lovely blog without any issues..Sadly not all are as fortunate as you. Things that some take for granted can be and are arduous for others. A helpful hint is most appreciated-Harriet- thank you? Do NOT assume that all are able to just navigate around on computers- we can’t. Do not assume that we all have internet access in our homes or on our phones. People w/ limited mobility who can’t just jump on over to the library are enjoying these lovely blogs. So next time give a hand up verses a kick in the heart..
Color of text is an accessibility consideration in web design.
Aren’t you blessed, Nicole to be able to see so well. Not all of us have that ability. Sometimes my husband has to read things to me. You seem to have very little charity in your heart.
You might want to adjust the color on your computer. I have dark Blue color on my computer.
So rude…
I agree. Web design needs to take into account visual challenges.
Wow, these look amazing. I can almost taste them through the screen. Bookmarking recipe for later, for sure.
Could you leave out the cocoa? My husband is allergic to cocoa.
Beth – I haven’t tried it without cocoa, but I’m sure you could leave it out. It will be lighter in color and the flavor might not be quite as deep, but since what you taste most is the molasses and honey anyway, I think you’ll be just fine! Be sure to add a few extra tablespoons of flour to compensate.
The cocoa just gives it a little ‘something’. But if your husband can’t have, substitute the same amount of instant coffee.
Believe me, it is out standing!
What a fabulous idea, ty so much for this….the potential is staggering for some people I know with cocoa issues!
I make this type of bread all the time. You do not need to use cocoa if you use Blackstrap Molasses which is a very dark molasses.
You can omit the cocoa, you will just have a lighter colored roll, you could also substitute 1 tbls of kitchen bouquet or as another poster mentioned, instant coffee.
Like a previous commenter asked, what purpose does the cocoa have? I have these rising right now,
I am soooo excited as Outback is probably my favorite bread of all time. I have a little one allergic to chocolate also. Wondering if I can omit it next time so she can enjoy this yummy bread too!?!?!?
The cocoa is there for color and a little depth of flavor, so I’m sure you could omit it. You’ll just need a few extra tablespoons of flour if you leave it out and the flavor won’t be quite as rich, but I don’t think it will change the flavor too much. I hope it turned out for you!
For those of us in the UK looking for a brown colouring- the caramel colouring you mentioned is sold here as ‘gravy browning’. A tiny amount goes a VERY long way, so be warned, and no it won’t make your bread taste like gravy because of the small amount used.
Thank Pamela! 🙂
I think the caramel coloring for this recipe is strictly brown food coloring, usually found at restaurant supply stores, etc (I found my quart bottle at GFS). The gravy browning I think you are referring to is also available here under other product names. I do believe they’re very different items. I haven’t shopped in England in many, many years, but was married to an Englishman for over 20, so I have some familiarity with the recipes and products. Browning sauce might indeed add an interesting flavor to this bread, though, and certainly would add the color. I never make beef stew without it. 🙂
Made there for my family. They really loved them. They are great warmed up as a snack! Thanks for sharing. I will be making yourbreadsticks next!
Some of the brown color you are looking for could be from graham flour. It also has some of that earthy, nutty sweetness.
Made these wonderful rolls this afternoon to have with dinner. They were very easy to make and were very good!
Can these be frozen and if so, would you freeze before or after baking???
Any yeast bread can be made the day before and placed in the frig over night. Just take it out in the morning and shape Into rolls or loaves. I place dough in a bread sack to prevent any drying out and this also allows for some rising.
back house stake house rolls
Could I throw all the ingredients in a breadmaker to make the dough for me?
I don’t see why not!
Glad to hear I can use my bread maker…I don’t do very well making bread “by hand”, I usually end up wasting precious ingredients! I will give this recipe a try, Outback Bread is my favorite bread of all time!
Can’t wait to try these. Also, unless they changed their recipe in the past 10 years, the butter is just whipped butter, there is no honey in it. I used to be a prep cook for Outback and it’s just butter and cream, whipped together.
good to know – thanks!
Honey butter is available on request!! I always request 🙂
I am planning to make these for Thanksgiving this year, and was wondering if I could make the dough the night before and leave the dough rising for the second time so I can save some prep time the day of. Do you think this will effect the rolls at all/ Have you or anyone else attempted this?
I haven’t tried that with these rolls. With the roll recipe I normally use, I often mix, first rise, and shape the rolls, then place them in the dish I plan to bake them in and cover with saran wrap, then put them in the fridge. Then you can pull them out and let them come to room temperature and rise for the second time – that probably takes about 90 min to 2 hours. I don’t see why it wouldn’t work with this recipe, I’ve just never tried it so I can’t say for sure! You might want to give it a test run before Thanksgiving 🙂
Hi Autumn, I have a recipe for outbacks bread also. Yours actually looks a lot better though, I will be trying it thank you so much. I just wanted to make a suggestion to those who are allergic to the cocoa. Since cocoa is used for color, you could replace with instant coffee granules. they do not change the taste. Thanks again.
Could you post your outbacks bread recipe?
Hi,
I’m having trouble making them soft. My dough was super moist. I put it in the warm oven for rising but when I took it out the rise went down. Please advise.
What would happen if I used all white flour, and no wheat? Would they turn out ok anyway? I’m sure it would affect the flavor some, but they should still bake up alright, not?
I didn’t have whole wheat flour, so I just used white unbleached. The rolls looked fabulous and tasted delicious. I took soft butter and added some cinnamon, nothing could be better. Thank you for the recipe.
Assembling all the ingredients to bake these today. Thanks so much for sharing! They look beautiful & delicious!
is it possible to make this in a loaf instead of rolls? If so, would there be any change to the process or baking time?
Process is the same for a loaf, but it needs to bake longer. If you have an instant read thermometer, 190 degrees is a good internal temp. Otherwise, probably 30-40 minutes to be baked through.
I mixed the dough in my bread machine. Didn’t change the ingredients except to add 2 tbps. of wheat gluten, which I always do when using whole wheat flour. Put the ingredients in my bread machine per manufacturer instructions (liquids on the bottom, solids on top, salt in with liquids) and then shaped the rolls. Froze half after shaping, baked the other half.
Final result? Amazing! Can’t wait to eat them for dinner tonight w/my homemade broccoli cheddar soup!
Hi, is it possible to use a hand mixer? I don’t have a mixer with the attachments that the recipe called for. Thanks 😉
Hi Lauren! If you want to make this without a mixer, you can start with your hand mixer. As you add in the bulk of the flour, however, it will get too thick to use your hand mixer, so you’ll just want to knead it by hand. Check out this video for help: http://www.kingarthurflour.com/videos/bread-101-basic-white-bread-kneading-techniques
good luck!
dumb question what are the little seeds or crumbs on top ? is that there on its own or do you sprinkle something on them?
Hi Stephanie! I just sprinkled a few oats on top before baking to make them look prettier for my photos. Purely ornamental!
I am making this recipe right now and am so excited. I found them browsing pinterest. I am a blogger whom is just starting out and was wondering if they turn out well if you would mind me writing a review in my own blog. I am positive they will be delicious. Thanks! ~ Nikki
Sure! I’d love a link back – thanks!
Found these on pinterest as well. Made them today and they were terrific. Thanks so much for such a delicious recipe. My hubby loved them!
Very nice bread, thanks for the recipe! I made some changes that worked out pretty well: 1. Cut the recipe in half for our small bread machine. 2. Substituted sourdough starter for the water. This left the dough dry, so added water to correct. Since I used a full egg (instead of a 1/2 egg), the dough then became too wet, so I added flour to correct. Dough was wet in the machine, which I prefer for sourdough growth. 3. Used the whole wheat dough machine setting (with 1 teaspoon of yeast, along with the sourdough starter); whole wheat setting gives a longer rise period. Even with this setting, though, it took about 6 hours (instead of the machine’s 3 1/2) to get sufficient rise. Slow rise due to a) lots of sugar in the dough, which suppresses yeast. b) not-too-active starter (I store it in the refrigerator, and don’t count on it for the rise, mostly just for flavor). Next time, I’ll use 2 teaspoons of yeast (which would have been the proper 1/2 recipe amount). 4. I had to increase the bake time (dough cooked in oven while still in the bread machine pan, did not make rolls). Even with extra time, the bottom of the loaf was not fully set; it was cooked, but soft. I just toasted the slices from the bottom of the loaf, and all was well in the eating 🙂
We ate the bread with actual left-over Outback whipped butter, totally delicious.
Thanks again, Autumn!
Did you use dutch-process cocoa or natural?
I use natural. I don’t think it would affect the flavor much to use dutch-process instead since you’re not really tasting the cocoa. Dutch-process has a bit of a redder color, though, so they may look slightly different.
do you think if using instant yeast with this recipe is workable too?
This is a Steakhouse bread recipe that I obtained many years ago from a friend. It makes a very dense and flavorful bread. If you like, brush the rolls or bread with beaten egg, then sprinkle some uncooked oatmeal on top before baking. Enjoy!
I made these yesterday and they turned out beautifully. This was very first attempt at bread of any sort, so I’m pretty excited at how easy they were to make and how well they turned out.
I used my food processor to combine the first ingredients and then switched to the dough hook when I added the whole wheat flour. It took about 2 minutes to completely pull away from the sides. Surprisingly simple and fast!
I also did the second rise overnight in the fridge. I was a little worried, but they came out beautifully.
Thanks for the great recipe!
I have attempted to make this recipe twice – to the letter – and I am an avid bread baker – and it just won’t rise for me. Just stays a dense ball of dough. I can’t figure it out. I can make another bread sitting right next to it without issue – for some reason this recipe does not want to cooperate with me. Another dough ball in the trash 🙁
Try giving your yeast a bit of extra sugar. I proofed my yeast with the brown sugar for the recipe. Also, whole wheat dough will need a bit of resting time for the whole wheat flour to hydrate, then need up to twice the rising time that a white flour dough will. The dough should be fairly damp, soft and sticky when you get it mixed. A dry dough won’t rise. Cover the bowl with a damp towel for the first rise.
Thanks for these tips!
I usually have trouble getting an getting anything to rise in my kitchen (not sure if temperature or moisture level in house??) I usually correct by placing rising dough in oven at lowest temperature and turning oven off when its preheated (leaving dough in) rises in about half to three-quarters of the time, too.
I tried these rolls and they are amazing! I did not use any food coloring, and the molasses and cocoa powder give the dough a beautiful brown color. I make bread a lot, and this is the best recipe ever. I just threw the ingredients in my bread machine and put it on the dough setting. At the end of the cycle, I gave it an extra 15 minutes to rise. Thank you for this recipe!
Hi – Can you make these ahead and either refrigerate or freeze and then pull out and cook?
To make these gluten free, I guess you could use an all purpose GF flour for the white flour, and what would you use in place of the brown flour? Thank-you
Sorry, I’m no help when it comes to gluten free – I have no idea!
Try brown rice flour. It has a nice nutty flavor and is similar in color to whole wheat flour.
I could eat Outback Steakhouses bread for DAYS! Thanks so much for sharing this recipe! I’m going to make immediately!
This is an amazing recipe for me! I only have 1 child but this recipe doesn’t take up a lot of time and I can spend more with her or doing other things and still have homemade bread! Plus it is nice you don’t have to stay home all day just to make bread!
I’ve used it for pizza too and I love it, Husband says its a little crispy so lets it sit a bit to let the steam soften it. 🙂 I wasn’t sure how i would like it pre-baking the crust so I experimented some and it works great to just put the dough on the stone cold, add toppings and bake! Still turned out super with a little thinner crust and also not quite as crispy. Thank you for posting!
oops ^^ I comment on the wrong recipe! Making this one for the first time! Can’t wait to try!
Do you know if the whole wheat you used is hard red or hard white?
Thanks,
Sorry, I’m not sure. I just buy the bags of whole wheat flour at the store and they don’t say which they are.
Make sure you just use normal cocoa powder, I accidentally used Hersey’s special dark and my rolls tasted like chocolate cake.
Oh darn! How disappointing. Although I do like chocolate cake 🙂 Anyway, thanks for letting us know!
This is good to know. I was going to use the special dark cocoa to give it a darker look. So glad I read your comment first.
This made me lol! But it sounds good! ?
This made me lol! It sounds goo! ?
So glad I found your blog through Pinterest. I just baked these babies today and boy was it a big treat. My Mom, Dad, and hubby loved it. My mom asked for the recipe, my Dad said it was very good, and the hubs said it was really good too. I even ran across the street in excitement and gave some to our neighbors. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe. Looking forward to trying some of your other recipes now. *(^ _ ^)*
Fantastic! That’s what we like to hear 🙂 I’m always way too proud of myself when I make bread. It’s not even *that* hard but it feels like a pretty big deal, you know? I’m glad to hear it went over so well!
I made this bread for a dinner party last week. Made two batches, the only change to the recipe was to use bread flour in place of all purpose. I shaped each batch into six small loaves. The bread came out wonderfully, and was a big hit. For my taste it’s just a little too sweet to be quite perfect, so next time I’ll probably cut back on the honey and brown sugar. I may also leave out the cocoa, it seemed to give the bread just a bit of bitter aftertaste.
I have made these almost daily (or at least every other day) for the last month. We love them. I switched up the amounts of molasses and honey because we love the molasses taste. Tonight I am going to try and make it into loaves to go with some chicken salad I made. After baking, I wrap two rolls each in foil while they are still hot. When we want one or two, 30 seconds in the microwave and they are almost like they just came out of the oven.
I’m so glad you love the recipe! I think it would be amazing with chicken salad – good luck!
Made a few small changes that makes this bread the best bread ever (for this household anyway). Cut the brown sugar back to one rounded teaspoon, added into your yeast as it proofs. Cut the cocoa back to one tablespoon, and be sure not to use Special Dark baking cocoa (too bitter). Use unbleached bread flour in place of all purpose (gives a chewier texture and better crumb). Add one or two more tablespoons of water near the end of kneading, your dough should be very soft and kind of wet. Brush your loaves or rolls lightly with water before letting them rise for the second time. Bake at 325 for about 18-21 minutes for small loaves. Bacon grease can be used instead of butter, doesn’t seem to make a noticeable difference in the finished bread. Might try olive oil as the fat next time.
Will this recipe still turn out if it is halved?
I don’t know why it wouldn’t!
why so much yeast? Most recipes call for one packet (2 1/4 tsp) this calls for 4 tsp. I have it rising for the first time right now with the 4 tsp indicated in the recipe. Could that be causing the bitterness everyone is talking about? What happens if i reduce the yeast?
Do I sub with as much 2 tbsp of coffee instead of cocoa? That much coffee?
I made these last night for my husband who loves Outback’s bread. They came out awesome. The honey butter makes the difference. Guess what I ate as my lunch today? lol
thanks for sharing this recipe i love brown bread. i well try it tomorrow.
I’m wondering why there’s no rye flour in yours? Every recipe I’ve ever seen/tried had rye flour instead of all purpose. Was there a reason you didn’t use rye?
Has anyone tried these in a bread machine?
Yes, I tried these in my bread machine today! They’re baking in the oven now! I followed a typical bread machine recipe by adding liquid ingredients first, then dry ingredients (flour & cocoa last), and yeast on top and set it on the dough cycle. It was so convenient! I can’t wait to devour them! 😛
This is the easiest bread recipe I’ve ever come across and it is better than store-bought…Thank you so much for posting your recipe. I mixed the dough in my bread machine.I put same ingredients. I followed all instructions. Froze half after shaping, baked the other half.
Finaly we saw great results. It was so delicious. But now I have some trouble because My husband loves it and he said he would never buy bread from store again 🙂
I made these last night and they were good! I only put 1 packet of yeast ( 2 1/4 tsp) instead of 4 teaspoons of yeast. Thanks for this recipe!
I made these and you hit it on the nose. Perfect. Just like down town. Thanks so much, I can eat these instead of my dinner.
Was wondering if anyone has made these with only AP white flour and not the wheat flour. If so was there any changes you had to make else where?
I found there are many recipes for this steakhouse bread and I already bought the Molasses. Now I have all ingredients u listed out, time to make! Thanks for sharing! 🙂
I always find bread recipe online, I like to cook for my family, and I also like to bake, thanks for your tips
Can you replace wheat flour with spelt flour?
Made these yesterday. Used my bread machine to make the dough then shaped into rolls and let rise an hour. My fam thought they were great-would only bake them maybe a few minutes less per our taste buds like a “softer roll.” And they do taste just like outbacks- we used Reg butter also- just fine. Thanks for the recipe!
Hi!! These rolls look amazing!!!cant wait to try them!!you did a wonderful job on making them~jennifer
My dough was a little heavy, didn’t seem to want to rise that much. Would using less wheat flour and adding more all purpose flour lighten it up a bit?? Like maybe a half cup less of the wheat maybe??
I can’t seem to get a good rise out of these and I’m not sure what I’m doing wrong. I know its not my yeast because I used it yesterday for another recipe and that came out fine. Could the fact that I’m halving the recipe have any effect on the outcome? I’ve tried this recipe twice now and it still have good flavor but it doesn’t rise correctly and get fluffy like it should. Any ideas?
I’ve been wanting to try this recipe for awhile and finally remembered to purchase molasses.
My first attempt was a flop — I followed recipe as written, and the taste was exactly as expected, but the rolls did not rise properly and thus the texture/consistency wasn’t right.
I tried it again the next day, and this time had success. It’s not scientific, but the things I changed were 1) Mixed the dough in my bread machine instead of my stand mixer, which adds that tiny bit of heat during the rise process, 2) I used real, unsalted butter instead of margarine, 3) I used bread flour instead of all-purpose flour, 4) I let the formed rolls rise in a slightly preheated oven instead of on the counter covered with a cloth.
Once I got the texture and rise correct, these were fantastic! They have a great taste, they are wonderful with butter, and a big hit at my house!
Thanks for your comments, Kristen! It does seem to be a touchy recipe and I’ve been trying to figure out why it works well for some people but doesn’t for others. This info will be very helpful!
I had a tough time on another recipe like this one where they didn’t rise. I almost failed the first time on these but they rose…what I did was made sure my yeast was room temp..then put in the very warm water…let sit for 5 mins then added the honey and brown sugar and let it sit for remaining 5_7mins….this gives the yeast the sugar it needs to start activating….then added the remaining wet ingredients….in separate bowl I did the flour, salt and cocoa…once I had all my wet nicely mixed, including softened butter nicely melted, I then added my dry to wet and kept mixing. Once dough was ready I put it in a slightly warmed oven for 90 minutes…
The trick is the yeast…not the flour. Although I assume you can use bread flour, I stuck with the all purpose unbleached and it worked fine. It rises slowly, but it rose nonetheless.
I made these today and enjoyed them with dinner tonight. They were so good! Very comparable to what you get at the restaurant! Thanks for sharing.
I made these yesterday EXACTLY as your recipe said and I am so amazed at how good they not only looked but the AMAZING taste!! You hit the nail on the head with this one!! I had people screaming at me to send them the recipe when I posted my goodies on Facebook! Bravo!!! And thank you!!
I’ve tried others but this is bar none the best recipe for making those to die for sweet rolls we all love from Outback!!!!
These went so far beyond my expectations! Thank you for writing an accurate recipe that tastes amazing! It is soooo disappointing to make recipes off of blogs and end up dumping everything in the trash because of mistakes in the recipe.
These were AMAZING and will be a regular roll on my dinner menu. My hubby and guests were so impressed!
I’ve tried to make this recipe twice and have had trouble getting it to rise both times. I’m not sure if I’m over working or under working the dough or adding too much flour. Could you please answer the following;
1. Should I be able to get a gluten window in this dough when it’s ready?
2. What speed do you have your mixer on when mixing for 7-10 mins? Mine has a kneading/folding speed which is quite slow.
3. How sticky should this dough be? I ended up adding about another 1.5 – 2 cups of flour to get it to come away from the sides of the bowl and whilst kneading by hand so that it didn’t stick to everything. A lot of this was white flour as I was worried that much whole wheat flour wouldn’t give enough gluten to rise.
Thank you for this recipe, am sure to try it real soon.
Thank you very much for sharing your recipe. I followed it exactly. These rolls are fabulous. My family loved them. Thank you again. Noelle
Would it affect the dough to substitute the whole wheat flour for more all-purpose flour? Or is it optional?
This is a great blog. I love eating and making bread myself. I have been looking for different bread recipes like this one. Thanks for sharing . I’m so excited to try this. Certainly it will be great. I love using my bread machine. After try this one , I will try your other bread recipes for my bread machine. I am looking forward to your other recipes:)
I’m so excited to have stumbled across this recipe! My husband is a huge bread lover. I can’t wait to surprise him with this! Thanks so much for sharing 🙂
For the wheat flour, are you using regular or bread flour?
I love this recipe….can not stop eating them. And the dough is so easy to work with.
These are so soft and moist and rich tasting! My husband especially enjoyed them. My kids were split; they were unfamiliar with these flavors in a bread. The girls loved them; the boys not so much. Thank you for the recipe!
I have made these delicious rolls the last 2 years for Thanksgiving and Christmas. My family loves them. I wanted to know if I could post your recipe on my sister’s and mine blog. I don’t put in the coloring but wanted to use your recipe with a link up to your blog for the original recipe. Let me know if that’s okay. Thanks!
Sorry, I am not at my desktop so please disregard the coloring thing. I use the cocoa for the coloring just like it says on your recipe. Again, so sorry for the confusion!
These look delicious!! Can’t wait to make them, what should I do if I want to make the dough today and cook them tomorrow??
What do I do differently to make this into a loaf of bread instead of dinner rolls?
I haven’t eaten at Outback in years so I don’t know how the two breads compare, but I do know that this is a delicious bread and on that I will be making often.
Were these dusted with corn meal? It looks like they are.
Nevermind that. I didn’t see it til I continued on. I need my glasses. ROFL
I made these tonight and they were a hit. Although… I don’t think my yeast was the best as I had trouble getting them to rise. Finally turned the oven on and then off, put them in the oven and they rose better with the second rise. I will certainly keep this recipe and make it again. Thank you for sharing.
What a fun change. Thank you for your hard work and sharing the recipe.
Hello, can’t wait to try , was wondering if can be made in glass loaf pans and if anyone has done this what is the baking time
Sweet bread is my favorite dish
I wonder if this would make good bread pudding? I think the flavor might be very surprising!
I bake bread frequently, and my bread is good!!!! But, this sure did not resemble rolls, more like hockey pucks!! I definitely did something very wrong!!!
Is it possible to make these without the cocoa? I really want to try them but can’t have cocoa!
I never have luck making bread. These were very heavy. My husband made the comment “do these have chocolate in them”. Don’t think I’ll be making these again
Molasses bread is supposed to be a heavier bread….. at least any I’ve consumed has been. I could be wrong.
I just made these and they are absolutely delicious and so simple to put together! Do you think they can be frozen? I’m thinking I may want to make them for Thanksgiving this year and with 35 guests I would have to bake in batches! Thanks again for sharing the recipe!
This bread looks great, can’t wait to try it! Thanks for posting it 🙂
Amazing. This outback rolls recipe is amazing. Thanks for sharing.
I tasted the dough and it tastes amazing, but I’m doing my first rise and it hasn’t grown ): It’s been an hour and a half. I must have killed the yeast somehow – I temped the water to make sure that didn’t happen. Who knows. Super bummed!
Dude, you have no idea how many questions of yester year this answers. That is a serious carb load in a little roll that accompanies shrimp on a skewer. I had no idea that there was molasses, cocoa, and dreaded honey in those little suckers. I no longer do much gluten, but I now feel enlightened.
I can’t bake! Outside burnt, inside raw. That’s what I’m known for. This is the first baking recipe that I made to perfection! WOW! I didn’t know it was possible. Finally my time, energy and $ weren’t wasted. Thank you!
I’m eating one right now. So amazing!!! I used our bread machine to mix and rise the dough (as I was preppeong dinner and getting ready for work) They are going to gobble these up tonight with dinner! We will reheat and serve. Def making these again
QUESTION: Could you possibly re-post the pdf with the first “Add” corrected from the “And” typo? You made me smile from ear-to-ear with this recipe! Thanks bunches!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The recipe that I’ve been using was for rolls and it looks like you just switched to loaves. Did any of the recipe particulars change when you switched to loaves? I’ve made the rolls 3 time and we LOVE them! I don’t have the recipe committed to memory and I don’t want to alter what I’ve been doing. 🙂
Thank you!
I did make a few changes small changes to the recipe to help them rise a bit better. Basically just used bread flour instead of all purpose and decreased the total flour a bit, plus I decreased the cocoa from 2 tablespoons to 1. Glad to hear it’s been working well for you!
I in addition to my guys have been following the excellent tips on your site then the sudden I had a horrible suspicion I had not thanked the website owner for those strategies. All the women were definitely totally excited to study all of them and have now simply been taking pleasure in them. Thank you for turning out to be considerably accommodating as well as for pick out this sort of incredible areas most people are really eager to be informed on. My very own sincere apologies for not expressing gratitude to you sooner.
Hi Autumn. Thank you so MUCH for this recipe. I must confess the warm molasses bread is the reason I go to the steakhouses in the first place. I’ve been trying to find a recipe to make at home that has that same great look and flavor! It’s been several attempts with sad results, until YOUR post of course. It was so soft, sweet, and flavorful!! I have a blog where I try new recipes, and so I am going to post my success and to link back to you, if that is okay. Since I was trying to make it more like the Blank Angus bread from our area, I did an egg wash at the end (before baking) and added some quick oats to the top to get that same look they have.